The legend. The GOAT. The fudge that makes us famous.
The Ultimate Peanut Butter Pie Experience — Handmade in San Francisco
This isn’t “peanut butter fudge.”
This isn’t even peanut butter pie.
This is seven layers of madness — a legendary, handcrafted fudge that’s earned its own fan club. Starting with a rich foundation of peanut butter fudge, we pile on crunchy Oreo crumble, gooey caramel, real marshmallow, and silky milk chocolate fudge. Then we sprinkle in crunchy Heath English Toffee pieces and crown the whole bar with a warm drizzle of hot peanut butter and caramel.
Seven layers.
Seven reasons to drop everything and take a bite.
It’s salty, sweet, crunchy, gooey, chocolate-covered chaos — in the best way possible.
If it had a theme song, it would be louder.
🧠 Why It’s More Than Just Fudge
- Signature seven-layer flavor bomb
- Peanut butter, Oreo crumble, caramel, marshmallow, milk chocolate and toffee
- Handmade small-batch gourmet fudge
- Perfect for gifting — or not sharing
- A standout best seller for a reason
Contains Gluten
Please allow 3-5 days for us to ship the freshest fudge.
Vicki L.
It was just okay, the layers actually took away from the fudge taste. Sorry ♀️
Eloise K.
The creamiest and best tasting fudge I have ever tasted five stars all the way
Amanda R.
Best fudge in the world hands down. Always arrives quick and fresh. My family loves it . Thank you!
M T.
The peanut butter pie fudge is what dreams are made of. That fudge alone has made me a regular, returning customer, and they have plenty of other flavors worth going back for too along with their stellar customer service. I'm just obsessed with this one particularly.
Beverly D.
The 7 layer Brownies I ordered are without a doubt, the most sinfully rich and decadent brownies I’ve ever tasted; they are beyond compare with any others I’ve tried before! The very best!!!
Sonya N.
Best fudge ever! Fast shipping/ delivery with great packaging! Totally recommend ordering from them!
Jeff N.
.
Cathi S.
Sent to my mom (93-y-o) in MI for Mother's Day. She is a peanut butter anything addict. She said it was the most wonderful thing she ever tasted and that's saying something because HER mother was a baker!
She got it pretty quick and she said it came nicely wrapped.
So THANK YOU! I will be ordering again.
Cathi Soullier
Ariel Santos B.
Received package perfectly fine and outstanding AND placed
in the refrigerator for safe
measure as I received the package the day before
Mother's Day...perfect timing!!
Five Star Rating Overall !!
John E.
Great fudge and prompt delivery.
Kay L.
Peanut butter pie. DELICIOUS! I am not a fan of fudge, usually too sweet. This was sweet but didn't clog my throat. I tried to pace myself but ate the whole thing. Most others look better than they taste but not this one. Highly recommended!!
Patricia M.
These are too rich for us. The pieces for us are big. One piece served 4 people. But none of us really thought it would be a repeat order for us. We found them flavorless and too thick. We didn’t think the layers matched together. The fudge was good by itself. I’m very sorry to the company but this was a no go for us. Plus the packaging should have had dry ice in it. The tops melted into the wrapping. They are also quite messy. Very fragile and crumbly. Thanks
Brenda N.
It was more than I expected. Wonderful! Thank you!
Caroline W.
Absolutely the best fudge I have ever tried.
Eva Marie N.
I sent the peanut butter pie to friends in Florida and they said the fudge was the best they ever had!!
Diane B.
The fudge is delicious! The customer service is outstanding and I will be ordering from them again..... and again
Heidi P.
Great tasting fudge (pie)! I will definitely order again. I might even drop into the store. Although I wish you were closer to Oakland. You make great products.. Keep on making great treats.
Heidi
Kim G.
This is my favorite flavor of the fudges offered! It's a very unique combination of flavors with the various layers. A perfect balance! I would recommend it to others!
Matthew V.
Super tasty and delicious! Highly recommend!
Sally W.
My friend did some work for me. All he wanted was PeanutButter pie. He was very happy with your product. I will order again in the future.
Curtis W.
Quite delivery. Look the taste. This is my third order.
Diane S.
So wonderful, tried it again and then this was my favorite. I agree with some of the other people in reviews, no need for the marshmallow. Not bad it just doesn't need it
Isaiah P.
Great taste fast shipping very high quality fudge customer service wonderful as slways
Leslie T.
The absolute best fudge I have ever tasted!
Joel H.
I have yet to try the with 2% white milk, but I have no doubt it will be SO GOOD. Thank you for checking on your customer & your product.
Michael A.
Best Fudge I have ever tasted I have already placed a 2nd order for more continue making a great product ... Guaranteed a Customer
Lynn W.
Skrumpdiliumptious!! Sooo creamy, peanut-buttery.
Farrell H.
Extremely delicious, but I found myself wanting the fudge more than the caramel and the marshmallows and the cookie stuff. I probably wouldn’t order it again I would just want to get peanut butter chocolate fudge because it’s a little bit too busy. At the same time extremely good, but left you for wanting more of the fudge part. I think they should think about the wrapper. It’s a little extra - like could survive active volcano - and the product gets stuck on it. Wax paper maybe better.
Omega A.
It was not creamy and smooth, it was spongey. Very disappointed. Did not seem fresh.
Erinn
Unbelievably good! I loved the marshmallow! Really brought all the flavors together, in my opinion. Super delicious!
Laurie Z.
Very good except for the marshmallow. That makes it super sticky and messy. I just don't like that part, but the rest is good.
Susan P.
It's simply amazing!!
Amanda
Best fudge on the west coast. Order super late and still got in time for Christmas. Thank you!
Susan P.
Soooo good, will order again
Brian
Jalesa
Amazing
Michael
AMAZING.
Michael C.
Good morning,
I gotta say that your fudge is AWESOME. I ended up with a pound of peanut butter pie fudge that was out of this world. It was creamy and rich and sweet and delicious according to family and coworkers. To me it was OUTSTANDING!!!!! I would recommend this to anyone with a sweet tooth.. and especially those with a love for fudge. 500 stars
Michael C.
Myong L.
Rich,Thick and absolutely delicious This is my 4th order From Z !!! Love their fudge Next time fudge and Salt Water Taffy!!
Kathy A.
Love your fudge but this peanut butter pie I didn’t care for. Disappointed that I bought four. Everything else has been great.
Kathleen
Excellent!!
BEVERLY H.
Unique and delicious!
Mary B.
My Mom loved this flavor too!
Melinda M.
Not that big of a peanut butter lover but thought I would try this. OMG is this good! I don't know what I expected, but I did not expect that. Now I have to order more since I only ordered the one piece of this fudge to sample.
Justin R.
This box of six delicate fudge arrived at the house and were savored. By savored I mean enjoyed and devoured by my wife and I in less than 3 days. The layers of flavor within Peanut Butter Pie words cannot define. You simply must taste it for yourself.
Marc A.
I was really expecting this to be amazing, after looking at the photos on the website. Unfortunately it was just okay. Nothing really special here. The flavors were rather bland but sweet.
Kevin S.
Fabulous product…..fabulous see!!
Lil M.
Fantastic
Rocky B.
There are no words. Ok, maybe a few. lol. This multi-layered flavor explosion defies description. Just placed my 7th order (one was a 12 piece gift) and was sure to include several pieces of this absolutely AWESOME creation! Goodness, gracious. lol.
Nicole P.
Well this amazing morsel of goodness may be one of the best desserts I've ever eaten! I didn't know what to expect especially with so many flavors combined but it was an explosion of sweetness. Best at room temp, I had to give a few pieces away so I didn't eat it all in one sitting, it's that good!!!
Sharen S.
This was the best fudge I have ever tasted! 5+++ stars. It was included in the Brenda Novak monthly book for her new book release, Seaside Library. I would have never known about your fudge if it weren’t for her. Delicious and delectable flavor. You must try!
RockyB
Wow. Wasn't expecting love at first bite, here...was worried the whole thing might be "just too much." Ominous storm clouds rolled on out, the wayward winds ceased blowing and glorious slantlight streamed through the old farmhouse windows as my happy heart rejoiced upon slicing into this beautiful hunka multi-layered goodness. Wow. Even the marshmallow cream element was "just right." Found myself mourning the last of the four slices of that beautiful beast of a hunka fudge. ANOTHER "new" favorite.
Edward H.
This was a birthday gift for my sister who loves peanut butter pie but this is the closest I could get to a peanut butter pie to be delivered and she loved it. She also told me there was taffy in the box as well which I did not know about so thank you for that which she really liked as well!!
James M.
Unbelievably rich and flavorful. Perfect for sharing with family and friends!
James
Unbelievably rich and flavorful! Share with friends and enjoy!
Cindy
I can’t find the words to explain just how good this fudge is.
Roberta P.
This is an awesome candy, love it.
Teresa J.
Half of this decadent fudge is almost gone , sharing is caring . More new customers are going to learn about the best fudge in the United States. I gave a family member ordering next week . Keep up the 7 layers flavors . Thank you
James K.
Delicious. Perfect if you love peanut butter and chocolate.
Michael F.
Wow Wow Wow, it was out of this world, we shared it with a large group of family and friends and they all loved it.
Amanda R.
Peanut butter pie hands down the best !!!!
Matthew V.
Stop reading this review. Seriously, stop. Quit now. Cease and desist! You're still reading? Very well, but you're wasting valuable time you could be using to order this delicious box of fudge. Super fast shipping, too. Pick any piece and you won't be disappointed. These guys don't miss. I could and have picked blindfolded from their list of flavors and it was tasty. Go order right now!
WILLIAM H.
it is the best we ever had
Grace S.
Was supposed to be a chocolate peanut butter pie, but had this thick marshmallow in it, hardly any peanut butter. Tasted more like a Smores taste
Frank O.
Its a whole new experience eating this! I am So hooked now! It has EVERYTHING I Love in it so it's a winner to me! I will be Definatly be ordering more and more! Thank you Mike a million times over for the fudge!
Leslie J.
The DELICIOUSNESS of the 7 layer peanut butter fudge is RIDICULOUS. You must use all you DISCIPLINE and WILLPOWER TO STOP EATING IT ONCE YOU TASTE IT.♥️
Shirley A.
Love !!!! My daughters favorite!
Barbara V.
Tastes wonderful love pb!
ernest h.
BAD BAD BAD FUDGE IT WAS GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Karen G.
THE BEST fudge I've EVER tasted. Will be ordering again and ordering for gifts. The flavor and texture and blending of layers was masterful. Please keep it up. I normally don't write reviews but this product deserves a trophy!!
Mildred H.
Delicious
Jack H.
I purchased the 6 piece box of Peanut Butter pie!! Absolutely delicious! I highly recommend.
Betsy N.
This is delicious. I love that each was nicely wrapped individually.
Mimi
This was my favorite of all the samples I tried. Each layer was perfect and so good.
Alexis M.
It was a birthday gift for a dear friend who loves chocolate. It arrived early and she loved it. As a new product, I was going by reviews and I am glad I did. I bought another order for my brother-in-law.
LISA K.
I am addicted, this fudge is amazing!!!
Sandy F.
This is the best fudge ever.
LISA K.
Absolutely a must have, so delicious!!!
Kim S.
Deeeelicious!!!!
Heidi M.
I had recently written a rather poor review of the box of fudge I got. I meant what I wrote. In a quick response, the owner wrote me a personal card apologizing for the apparent bad batch and very kindly sent me a new box of four of their fudges ( including what I previously bought). I must say I am very impressed. All of it was delicious! And to be so nice to send me more was a great gesture. Thank you very much. Way to do business
LISA K.
Definitely worth ordering! Looking forward to having this fudge again!
April V.
When I want to treat myself to something really special I buy fudge from this company! It's fabulous and always shipped promptly. April
Arnold D.
It was a great gift.
Chrisrtina H.
Absolutely delish! Highly recommended!
Heidi M.
Pretty disappointed. For an expensive small box of fudge, the four squares were mostly comprised of peanut butter. That taste overtook any of the other ingredients. Don’t think I will be ordering again
Tammy A.
I ordered this for my Dad for Father’s Day because I saw it on Facebook and I took a chance. He loves it and said it was excellent and very fresh! I would recommend to give it a try it makes a excellent gift for some one you love ❤️
Crystal S.
I don’t even like fudge…so, I thought! This fudge is so delicious. I generally don’t like fudge because it is too sweet, this flavor combination is perfect and the decadence is welcoming.
Nichole E.
This was good but it had so much marshmallow fluff on mine it made it hard to cut or taste the fudge part. I still liked it but I feel some of the other flavors are better (I’m looking at you, Black Panther)…
john t.
Absolutely wonderful! I will buy more!
Joan B.
Delightfully delicious!
Polly T.
ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!!
Suzanne A.
Amazing flavor
Mark H.
Phenomenal fudge!! What else can you say!! Flavor explosion!!
Roseann S.
Definitely a cheat snack.
Alice D.
Peanut butter pie is one of my favorites.
Ernest S.
It is amazing!
Melinda C.
This Peanut Butter Fudge Pie I sent to my brother in Texas for a gift ..He absolutely loved it ! I will be ordering the different flavors very soon for myself and gifts for others .. there are sooo many flavor combinations to choose from or you can create your own - THANK YOU SO MUCH !!
LaNae D.
Best fudge ever!!!
Zeena C.
Happy to be 100th star review! This stuff tastes amazing, the only fudge I could actually eat in one sitting because it's actually that good haha
Denise L.
Can't share a picture. Between my son and I, it's almost gone. Guess that pretty much says how scrumptious it is.
Vicki L.
It was just okay, the layers actually took away from the fudge taste. Sorry ♀️
Eloise K.
The creamiest and best tasting fudge I have ever tasted five stars all the way
Amanda R.
Best fudge in the world hands down. Always arrives quick and fresh. My family loves it . Thank you!
M T.
The peanut butter pie fudge is what dreams are made of. That fudge alone has made me a regular, returning customer, and they have plenty of other flavors worth going back for too along with their stellar customer service. I'm just obsessed with this one particularly.
Beverly D.
The 7 layer Brownies I ordered are without a doubt, the most sinfully rich and decadent brownies I’ve ever tasted; they are beyond compare with any others I’ve tried before! The very best!!!
Sonya N.
Best fudge ever! Fast shipping/ delivery with great packaging! Totally recommend ordering from them!
Jeff N.
.
Cathi S.
Sent to my mom (93-y-o) in MI for Mother's Day. She is a peanut butter anything addict. She said it was the most wonderful thing she ever tasted and that's saying something because HER mother was a baker!
She got it pretty quick and she said it came nicely wrapped.
So THANK YOU! I will be ordering again.
Cathi Soullier
Ariel Santos B.
Received package perfectly fine and outstanding AND placed
in the refrigerator for safe
measure as I received the package the day before
Mother's Day...perfect timing!!
Five Star Rating Overall !!
John E.
Great fudge and prompt delivery.
Kay L.
Peanut butter pie. DELICIOUS! I am not a fan of fudge, usually too sweet. This was sweet but didn't clog my throat. I tried to pace myself but ate the whole thing. Most others look better than they taste but not this one. Highly recommended!!
Patricia M.
These are too rich for us. The pieces for us are big. One piece served 4 people. But none of us really thought it would be a repeat order for us. We found them flavorless and too thick. We didn’t think the layers matched together. The fudge was good by itself. I’m very sorry to the company but this was a no go for us. Plus the packaging should have had dry ice in it. The tops melted into the wrapping. They are also quite messy. Very fragile and crumbly. Thanks
Brenda N.
It was more than I expected. Wonderful! Thank you!
Caroline W.
Absolutely the best fudge I have ever tried.
Eva Marie N.
I sent the peanut butter pie to friends in Florida and they said the fudge was the best they ever had!!
Diane B.
The fudge is delicious! The customer service is outstanding and I will be ordering from them again..... and again
Heidi P.
Great tasting fudge (pie)! I will definitely order again. I might even drop into the store. Although I wish you were closer to Oakland. You make great products.. Keep on making great treats.
Heidi
Kim G.
This is my favorite flavor of the fudges offered! It's a very unique combination of flavors with the various layers. A perfect balance! I would recommend it to others!
Matthew V.
Super tasty and delicious! Highly recommend!
Sally W.
My friend did some work for me. All he wanted was PeanutButter pie. He was very happy with your product. I will order again in the future.
Curtis W.
Quite delivery. Look the taste. This is my third order.
Diane S.
So wonderful, tried it again and then this was my favorite. I agree with some of the other people in reviews, no need for the marshmallow. Not bad it just doesn't need it
Isaiah P.
Great taste fast shipping very high quality fudge customer service wonderful as slways
Leslie T.
The absolute best fudge I have ever tasted!
Joel H.
I have yet to try the with 2% white milk, but I have no doubt it will be SO GOOD. Thank you for checking on your customer & your product.
Michael A.
Best Fudge I have ever tasted I have already placed a 2nd order for more continue making a great product ... Guaranteed a Customer
Lynn W.
Skrumpdiliumptious!! Sooo creamy, peanut-buttery.
Farrell H.
Extremely delicious, but I found myself wanting the fudge more than the caramel and the marshmallows and the cookie stuff. I probably wouldn’t order it again I would just want to get peanut butter chocolate fudge because it’s a little bit too busy. At the same time extremely good, but left you for wanting more of the fudge part. I think they should think about the wrapper. It’s a little extra - like could survive active volcano - and the product gets stuck on it. Wax paper maybe better.
Omega A.
It was not creamy and smooth, it was spongey. Very disappointed. Did not seem fresh.
Erinn
Unbelievably good! I loved the marshmallow! Really brought all the flavors together, in my opinion. Super delicious!
Laurie Z.
Very good except for the marshmallow. That makes it super sticky and messy. I just don't like that part, but the rest is good.
Susan P.
It's simply amazing!!
Amanda
Best fudge on the west coast. Order super late and still got in time for Christmas. Thank you!
Susan P.
Soooo good, will order again
Brian
Jalesa
Amazing
Michael
AMAZING.
Michael C.
Good morning,
I gotta say that your fudge is AWESOME. I ended up with a pound of peanut butter pie fudge that was out of this world. It was creamy and rich and sweet and delicious according to family and coworkers. To me it was OUTSTANDING!!!!! I would recommend this to anyone with a sweet tooth.. and especially those with a love for fudge. 500 stars
Michael C.
Myong L.
Rich,Thick and absolutely delicious This is my 4th order From Z !!! Love their fudge Next time fudge and Salt Water Taffy!!
Kathy A.
Love your fudge but this peanut butter pie I didn’t care for. Disappointed that I bought four. Everything else has been great.
Kathleen
Excellent!!
BEVERLY H.
Unique and delicious!
Mary B.
My Mom loved this flavor too!
Melinda M.
Not that big of a peanut butter lover but thought I would try this. OMG is this good! I don't know what I expected, but I did not expect that. Now I have to order more since I only ordered the one piece of this fudge to sample.
Justin R.
This box of six delicate fudge arrived at the house and were savored. By savored I mean enjoyed and devoured by my wife and I in less than 3 days. The layers of flavor within Peanut Butter Pie words cannot define. You simply must taste it for yourself.
Marc A.
I was really expecting this to be amazing, after looking at the photos on the website. Unfortunately it was just okay. Nothing really special here. The flavors were rather bland but sweet.
Kevin S.
Fabulous product…..fabulous see!!
Lil M.
Fantastic
Rocky B.
There are no words. Ok, maybe a few. lol. This multi-layered flavor explosion defies description. Just placed my 7th order (one was a 12 piece gift) and was sure to include several pieces of this absolutely AWESOME creation! Goodness, gracious. lol.
Nicole P.
Well this amazing morsel of goodness may be one of the best desserts I've ever eaten! I didn't know what to expect especially with so many flavors combined but it was an explosion of sweetness. Best at room temp, I had to give a few pieces away so I didn't eat it all in one sitting, it's that good!!!
Sharen S.
This was the best fudge I have ever tasted! 5+++ stars. It was included in the Brenda Novak monthly book for her new book release, Seaside Library. I would have never known about your fudge if it weren’t for her. Delicious and delectable flavor. You must try!
RockyB
Wow. Wasn't expecting love at first bite, here...was worried the whole thing might be "just too much." Ominous storm clouds rolled on out, the wayward winds ceased blowing and glorious slantlight streamed through the old farmhouse windows as my happy heart rejoiced upon slicing into this beautiful hunka multi-layered goodness. Wow. Even the marshmallow cream element was "just right." Found myself mourning the last of the four slices of that beautiful beast of a hunka fudge. ANOTHER "new" favorite.
Edward H.
This was a birthday gift for my sister who loves peanut butter pie but this is the closest I could get to a peanut butter pie to be delivered and she loved it. She also told me there was taffy in the box as well which I did not know about so thank you for that which she really liked as well!!
James M.
Unbelievably rich and flavorful. Perfect for sharing with family and friends!
James
Unbelievably rich and flavorful! Share with friends and enjoy!
Cindy
I can’t find the words to explain just how good this fudge is.
Roberta P.
This is an awesome candy, love it.
Teresa J.
Half of this decadent fudge is almost gone , sharing is caring . More new customers are going to learn about the best fudge in the United States. I gave a family member ordering next week . Keep up the 7 layers flavors . Thank you
James K.
Delicious. Perfect if you love peanut butter and chocolate.
Michael F.
Wow Wow Wow, it was out of this world, we shared it with a large group of family and friends and they all loved it.
Amanda R.
Peanut butter pie hands down the best !!!!
Matthew V.
Stop reading this review. Seriously, stop. Quit now. Cease and desist! You're still reading? Very well, but you're wasting valuable time you could be using to order this delicious box of fudge. Super fast shipping, too. Pick any piece and you won't be disappointed. These guys don't miss. I could and have picked blindfolded from their list of flavors and it was tasty. Go order right now!
WILLIAM H.
it is the best we ever had
Grace S.
Was supposed to be a chocolate peanut butter pie, but had this thick marshmallow in it, hardly any peanut butter. Tasted more like a Smores taste
Frank O.
Its a whole new experience eating this! I am So hooked now! It has EVERYTHING I Love in it so it's a winner to me! I will be Definatly be ordering more and more! Thank you Mike a million times over for the fudge!
Leslie J.
The DELICIOUSNESS of the 7 layer peanut butter fudge is RIDICULOUS. You must use all you DISCIPLINE and WILLPOWER TO STOP EATING IT ONCE YOU TASTE IT.♥️
Shirley A.
Love !!!! My daughters favorite!
Barbara V.
Tastes wonderful love pb!
ernest h.
BAD BAD BAD FUDGE IT WAS GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Karen G.
THE BEST fudge I've EVER tasted. Will be ordering again and ordering for gifts. The flavor and texture and blending of layers was masterful. Please keep it up. I normally don't write reviews but this product deserves a trophy!!
Mildred H.
Delicious
Jack H.
I purchased the 6 piece box of Peanut Butter pie!! Absolutely delicious! I highly recommend.
Betsy N.
This is delicious. I love that each was nicely wrapped individually.
Mimi
This was my favorite of all the samples I tried. Each layer was perfect and so good.
Alexis M.
It was a birthday gift for a dear friend who loves chocolate. It arrived early and she loved it. As a new product, I was going by reviews and I am glad I did. I bought another order for my brother-in-law.
LISA K.
I am addicted, this fudge is amazing!!!
Sandy F.
This is the best fudge ever.
LISA K.
Absolutely a must have, so delicious!!!
Kim S.
Deeeelicious!!!!
Heidi M.
I had recently written a rather poor review of the box of fudge I got. I meant what I wrote. In a quick response, the owner wrote me a personal card apologizing for the apparent bad batch and very kindly sent me a new box of four of their fudges ( including what I previously bought). I must say I am very impressed. All of it was delicious! And to be so nice to send me more was a great gesture. Thank you very much. Way to do business
LISA K.
Definitely worth ordering! Looking forward to having this fudge again!
April V.
When I want to treat myself to something really special I buy fudge from this company! It's fabulous and always shipped promptly. April
Arnold D.
It was a great gift.
Chrisrtina H.
Absolutely delish! Highly recommended!
Heidi M.
Pretty disappointed. For an expensive small box of fudge, the four squares were mostly comprised of peanut butter. That taste overtook any of the other ingredients. Don’t think I will be ordering again
Tammy A.
I ordered this for my Dad for Father’s Day because I saw it on Facebook and I took a chance. He loves it and said it was excellent and very fresh! I would recommend to give it a try it makes a excellent gift for some one you love ❤️
Crystal S.
I don’t even like fudge…so, I thought! This fudge is so delicious. I generally don’t like fudge because it is too sweet, this flavor combination is perfect and the decadence is welcoming.
Nichole E.
This was good but it had so much marshmallow fluff on mine it made it hard to cut or taste the fudge part. I still liked it but I feel some of the other flavors are better (I’m looking at you, Black Panther)…
john t.
Absolutely wonderful! I will buy more!
Joan B.
Delightfully delicious!
Polly T.
ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!!
Suzanne A.
Amazing flavor
Mark H.
Phenomenal fudge!! What else can you say!! Flavor explosion!!
Roseann S.
Definitely a cheat snack.
Alice D.
Peanut butter pie is one of my favorites.
Ernest S.
It is amazing!
Melinda C.
This Peanut Butter Fudge Pie I sent to my brother in Texas for a gift ..He absolutely loved it ! I will be ordering the different flavors very soon for myself and gifts for others .. there are sooo many flavor combinations to choose from or you can create your own - THANK YOU SO MUCH !!
LaNae D.
Best fudge ever!!!
Zeena C.
Happy to be 100th star review! This stuff tastes amazing, the only fudge I could actually eat in one sitting because it's actually that good haha
Denise L.
Can't share a picture. Between my son and I, it's almost gone. Guess that pretty much says how scrumptious it is.
Vicki L.
It was just okay, the layers actually took away from the fudge taste. Sorry ♀️
Eloise K.
The creamiest and best tasting fudge I have ever tasted five stars all the way
Amanda R.
Best fudge in the world hands down. Always arrives quick and fresh. My family loves it . Thank you!
M T.
The peanut butter pie fudge is what dreams are made of. That fudge alone has made me a regular, returning customer, and they have plenty of other flavors worth going back for too along with their stellar customer service. I'm just obsessed with this one particularly.
Beverly D.
The 7 layer Brownies I ordered are without a doubt, the most sinfully rich and decadent brownies I’ve ever tasted; they are beyond compare with any others I’ve tried before! The very best!!!
Sonya N.
Best fudge ever! Fast shipping/ delivery with great packaging! Totally recommend ordering from them!
Jeff N.
.
Cathi S.
Sent to my mom (93-y-o) in MI for Mother's Day. She is a peanut butter anything addict. She said it was the most wonderful thing she ever tasted and that's saying something because HER mother was a baker!
She got it pretty quick and she said it came nicely wrapped.
So THANK YOU! I will be ordering again.
Cathi Soullier
Ariel Santos B.
Received package perfectly fine and outstanding AND placed
in the refrigerator for safe
measure as I received the package the day before
Mother's Day...perfect timing!!
Five Star Rating Overall !!
John E.
Great fudge and prompt delivery.
Kay L.
Peanut butter pie. DELICIOUS! I am not a fan of fudge, usually too sweet. This was sweet but didn't clog my throat. I tried to pace myself but ate the whole thing. Most others look better than they taste but not this one. Highly recommended!!
Patricia M.
These are too rich for us. The pieces for us are big. One piece served 4 people. But none of us really thought it would be a repeat order for us. We found them flavorless and too thick. We didn’t think the layers matched together. The fudge was good by itself. I’m very sorry to the company but this was a no go for us. Plus the packaging should have had dry ice in it. The tops melted into the wrapping. They are also quite messy. Very fragile and crumbly. Thanks
Brenda N.
It was more than I expected. Wonderful! Thank you!
Caroline W.
Absolutely the best fudge I have ever tried.
Eva Marie N.
I sent the peanut butter pie to friends in Florida and they said the fudge was the best they ever had!!
Diane B.
The fudge is delicious! The customer service is outstanding and I will be ordering from them again..... and again
Heidi P.
Great tasting fudge (pie)! I will definitely order again. I might even drop into the store. Although I wish you were closer to Oakland. You make great products.. Keep on making great treats.
Heidi
Kim G.
This is my favorite flavor of the fudges offered! It's a very unique combination of flavors with the various layers. A perfect balance! I would recommend it to others!
Matthew V.
Super tasty and delicious! Highly recommend!
Sally W.
My friend did some work for me. All he wanted was PeanutButter pie. He was very happy with your product. I will order again in the future.
Curtis W.
Quite delivery. Look the taste. This is my third order.
Diane S.
So wonderful, tried it again and then this was my favorite. I agree with some of the other people in reviews, no need for the marshmallow. Not bad it just doesn't need it
Isaiah P.
Great taste fast shipping very high quality fudge customer service wonderful as slways
Leslie T.
The absolute best fudge I have ever tasted!
Joel H.
I have yet to try the with 2% white milk, but I have no doubt it will be SO GOOD. Thank you for checking on your customer & your product.
Michael A.
Best Fudge I have ever tasted I have already placed a 2nd order for more continue making a great product ... Guaranteed a Customer
Lynn W.
Skrumpdiliumptious!! Sooo creamy, peanut-buttery.
Farrell H.
Extremely delicious, but I found myself wanting the fudge more than the caramel and the marshmallows and the cookie stuff. I probably wouldn’t order it again I would just want to get peanut butter chocolate fudge because it’s a little bit too busy. At the same time extremely good, but left you for wanting more of the fudge part. I think they should think about the wrapper. It’s a little extra - like could survive active volcano - and the product gets stuck on it. Wax paper maybe better.
Omega A.
It was not creamy and smooth, it was spongey. Very disappointed. Did not seem fresh.
Erinn
Unbelievably good! I loved the marshmallow! Really brought all the flavors together, in my opinion. Super delicious!
Laurie Z.
Very good except for the marshmallow. That makes it super sticky and messy. I just don't like that part, but the rest is good.
Susan P.
It's simply amazing!!
Amanda
Best fudge on the west coast. Order super late and still got in time for Christmas. Thank you!
Susan P.
Soooo good, will order again
Brian
Jalesa
Amazing
Michael
AMAZING.
Michael C.
Good morning,
I gotta say that your fudge is AWESOME. I ended up with a pound of peanut butter pie fudge that was out of this world. It was creamy and rich and sweet and delicious according to family and coworkers. To me it was OUTSTANDING!!!!! I would recommend this to anyone with a sweet tooth.. and especially those with a love for fudge. 500 stars
Michael C.
Myong L.
Rich,Thick and absolutely delicious This is my 4th order From Z !!! Love their fudge Next time fudge and Salt Water Taffy!!
Kathy A.
Love your fudge but this peanut butter pie I didn’t care for. Disappointed that I bought four. Everything else has been great.
Kathleen
Excellent!!
BEVERLY H.
Unique and delicious!
Mary B.
My Mom loved this flavor too!
Melinda M.
Not that big of a peanut butter lover but thought I would try this. OMG is this good! I don't know what I expected, but I did not expect that. Now I have to order more since I only ordered the one piece of this fudge to sample.
Justin R.
This box of six delicate fudge arrived at the house and were savored. By savored I mean enjoyed and devoured by my wife and I in less than 3 days. The layers of flavor within Peanut Butter Pie words cannot define. You simply must taste it for yourself.
Marc A.
I was really expecting this to be amazing, after looking at the photos on the website. Unfortunately it was just okay. Nothing really special here. The flavors were rather bland but sweet.
Kevin S.
Fabulous product…..fabulous see!!
Lil M.
Fantastic
Rocky B.
There are no words. Ok, maybe a few. lol. This multi-layered flavor explosion defies description. Just placed my 7th order (one was a 12 piece gift) and was sure to include several pieces of this absolutely AWESOME creation! Goodness, gracious. lol.
Nicole P.
Well this amazing morsel of goodness may be one of the best desserts I've ever eaten! I didn't know what to expect especially with so many flavors combined but it was an explosion of sweetness. Best at room temp, I had to give a few pieces away so I didn't eat it all in one sitting, it's that good!!!
Sharen S.
This was the best fudge I have ever tasted! 5+++ stars. It was included in the Brenda Novak monthly book for her new book release, Seaside Library. I would have never known about your fudge if it weren’t for her. Delicious and delectable flavor. You must try!
RockyB
Wow. Wasn't expecting love at first bite, here...was worried the whole thing might be "just too much." Ominous storm clouds rolled on out, the wayward winds ceased blowing and glorious slantlight streamed through the old farmhouse windows as my happy heart rejoiced upon slicing into this beautiful hunka multi-layered goodness. Wow. Even the marshmallow cream element was "just right." Found myself mourning the last of the four slices of that beautiful beast of a hunka fudge. ANOTHER "new" favorite.
Edward H.
This was a birthday gift for my sister who loves peanut butter pie but this is the closest I could get to a peanut butter pie to be delivered and she loved it. She also told me there was taffy in the box as well which I did not know about so thank you for that which she really liked as well!!
James M.
Unbelievably rich and flavorful. Perfect for sharing with family and friends!
James
Unbelievably rich and flavorful! Share with friends and enjoy!
Cindy
I can’t find the words to explain just how good this fudge is.
Roberta P.
This is an awesome candy, love it.
Teresa J.
Half of this decadent fudge is almost gone , sharing is caring . More new customers are going to learn about the best fudge in the United States. I gave a family member ordering next week . Keep up the 7 layers flavors . Thank you
James K.
Delicious. Perfect if you love peanut butter and chocolate.
Michael F.
Wow Wow Wow, it was out of this world, we shared it with a large group of family and friends and they all loved it.
Amanda R.
Peanut butter pie hands down the best !!!!
Matthew V.
Stop reading this review. Seriously, stop. Quit now. Cease and desist! You're still reading? Very well, but you're wasting valuable time you could be using to order this delicious box of fudge. Super fast shipping, too. Pick any piece and you won't be disappointed. These guys don't miss. I could and have picked blindfolded from their list of flavors and it was tasty. Go order right now!
WILLIAM H.
it is the best we ever had
Grace S.
Was supposed to be a chocolate peanut butter pie, but had this thick marshmallow in it, hardly any peanut butter. Tasted more like a Smores taste
Frank O.
Its a whole new experience eating this! I am So hooked now! It has EVERYTHING I Love in it so it's a winner to me! I will be Definatly be ordering more and more! Thank you Mike a million times over for the fudge!
Leslie J.
The DELICIOUSNESS of the 7 layer peanut butter fudge is RIDICULOUS. You must use all you DISCIPLINE and WILLPOWER TO STOP EATING IT ONCE YOU TASTE IT.♥️
Shirley A.
Love !!!! My daughters favorite!
Barbara V.
Tastes wonderful love pb!
ernest h.
BAD BAD BAD FUDGE IT WAS GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Karen G.
THE BEST fudge I've EVER tasted. Will be ordering again and ordering for gifts. The flavor and texture and blending of layers was masterful. Please keep it up. I normally don't write reviews but this product deserves a trophy!!
Mildred H.
Delicious
Jack H.
I purchased the 6 piece box of Peanut Butter pie!! Absolutely delicious! I highly recommend.
Betsy N.
This is delicious. I love that each was nicely wrapped individually.
Mimi
This was my favorite of all the samples I tried. Each layer was perfect and so good.
Alexis M.
It was a birthday gift for a dear friend who loves chocolate. It arrived early and she loved it. As a new product, I was going by reviews and I am glad I did. I bought another order for my brother-in-law.
LISA K.
I am addicted, this fudge is amazing!!!
Sandy F.
This is the best fudge ever.
LISA K.
Absolutely a must have, so delicious!!!
Kim S.
Deeeelicious!!!!
Heidi M.
I had recently written a rather poor review of the box of fudge I got. I meant what I wrote. In a quick response, the owner wrote me a personal card apologizing for the apparent bad batch and very kindly sent me a new box of four of their fudges ( including what I previously bought). I must say I am very impressed. All of it was delicious! And to be so nice to send me more was a great gesture. Thank you very much. Way to do business
LISA K.
Definitely worth ordering! Looking forward to having this fudge again!
April V.
When I want to treat myself to something really special I buy fudge from this company! It's fabulous and always shipped promptly. April
Arnold D.
It was a great gift.
Chrisrtina H.
Absolutely delish! Highly recommended!
Heidi M.
Pretty disappointed. For an expensive small box of fudge, the four squares were mostly comprised of peanut butter. That taste overtook any of the other ingredients. Don’t think I will be ordering again
Tammy A.
I ordered this for my Dad for Father’s Day because I saw it on Facebook and I took a chance. He loves it and said it was excellent and very fresh! I would recommend to give it a try it makes a excellent gift for some one you love ❤️
Crystal S.
I don’t even like fudge…so, I thought! This fudge is so delicious. I generally don’t like fudge because it is too sweet, this flavor combination is perfect and the decadence is welcoming.
Nichole E.
This was good but it had so much marshmallow fluff on mine it made it hard to cut or taste the fudge part. I still liked it but I feel some of the other flavors are better (I’m looking at you, Black Panther)…
john t.
Absolutely wonderful! I will buy more!
Joan B.
Delightfully delicious!
Polly T.
ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!!
Suzanne A.
Amazing flavor
Mark H.
Phenomenal fudge!! What else can you say!! Flavor explosion!!
Roseann S.
Definitely a cheat snack.
Alice D.
Peanut butter pie is one of my favorites.
Ernest S.
It is amazing!
Melinda C.
This Peanut Butter Fudge Pie I sent to my brother in Texas for a gift ..He absolutely loved it ! I will be ordering the different flavors very soon for myself and gifts for others .. there are sooo many flavor combinations to choose from or you can create your own - THANK YOU SO MUCH !!
LaNae D.
Best fudge ever!!!
Zeena C.
Happy to be 100th star review! This stuff tastes amazing, the only fudge I could actually eat in one sitting because it's actually that good haha
Denise L.
Can't share a picture. Between my son and I, it's almost gone. Guess that pretty much says how scrumptious it is.