Choose Your Own Fudge Box

Open six-piece Z. Cioccolato box filled with assorted gourmet fudge

Build your own fudge gift box with small-batch San Francisco fudge from Z. Cioccolato. Pick your favorites. Double up on your obsessions. Make a box that’s all you.

Choose a 6, 9, 12, or 20-piece box, then mix and match your favorite fudge flavors. Try a little of everything, or go all in on that one flavor you refuse to share.

A fudge gift for someone sweet—or a well-earned treat for yourself. Your box. Your rules. We’ll handle the fudge.

How to build your box

  1. Choose your box size.
    Pick a 6, 9, 12, or 20-piece box below.
  2. Pick your flavors.
    Use the + and − buttons to choose how many pieces of each flavor you want.
  3. Fill it, then add to cart.
    Watch the piece counter. Once your box is full, you’re ready to add it to your cart.

Choose Your Flavors

0 / 0 selected
7 Layer Peanut Butter Pie: The G.O.A.T.

7 Layer Peanut Butter Pie: The G.O.A.T.

The legend. The G.O.A.T. Seven layers of sweet, salty, crunchy, and gooey flavor make this peanut butter pie fudge one of our signature creations.

The Layers

Peanut butter fudge is layered with Oreo crumble, caramel, marshmallow, and milk chocolate fudge, with Heath English Toffee pieces and a peanut butter-and-caramel drizzle.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Signature seven-layer combination
  • Peanut butter, Oreo crumble, and milk chocolate fudge
  • Caramel, marshmallow, and Heath English Toffee
  • Handmade in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Peanut butter pie fans, layered-fudge lovers, and a gift you may decide not to share.

Contains gluten.

Please allow 3–5 days for us to ship the freshest fudge.

Birthday Cake: It’s My Birthday!

Birthday Cake: It’s My Birthday!

All the joy of a birthday party, in a square. It’s My Birthday! pairs dark chocolate fudge with yellow cake-flavored fudge and colorful sprinkles.

The Layers

Rich dark chocolate fudge is layered with yellow cake-flavored fudge and finished with rainbow sprinkles. The vanilla layer uses yellow cake flavoring and yellow coloring.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Dark chocolate and yellow cake flavors
  • Rainbow sprinkles for a festive finish
  • Thick, creamy, hand-cut pieces
  • A birthday cake-inspired treat without the fork

Perfect For

Birthdays, celebrations, dessert gifts, and anyone who wants a little party in their fudge box.

Black Forest Cake: Will You Cherry Me?

Black Forest Cake: Will You Cherry Me?

Chocolate, cherries, and a little commitment issue. Will You Cherry Me? turns classic Black Forest cake flavor into handcrafted fudge.

The Layers

Dark chocolate fudge packed with real cake pieces is layered with whipped cream fudge and topped with candied cherries.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Real cake pieces in dark chocolate fudge
  • A creamy whipped cream fudge layer
  • Sweet candied cherries on top
  • Handcrafted in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Chocolate lovers, Black Forest cake fans, birthday gifts, and dessert tables.

Contains: Gluten.

Please allow 3–5 days for us to prepare and ship your fresh fudge.

Black Panther Truffle: Chocolate • Caramel • Peanut Butter • Sea Salt

Black Panther Truffle: Chocolate • Caramel • Peanut Butter • Sea Salt

Chocolate and peanut butter, turned up a little. Black Panther Truffle brings two kinds of chocolate fudge together with peanut butter, caramel, and sea salt.

The Layers

Dark and milk chocolate fudge are layered with creamy peanut butter and silky caramel, then finished with sea salt.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Dark and milk chocolate fudge
  • Creamy peanut butter
  • Silky caramel and a sea salt finish
  • Handmade in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Chocolate-and-peanut-butter lovers, caramel fans, and anyone who likes a sweet-and-salty layered fudge.

Gluten-free.

Butterscotch: Scotch Me Outside

Butterscotch: Scotch Me Outside

Buttery butterscotch, caramel, and sea salt make Scotch Me Outside a sweet-and-salty fudge with plenty of personality.

The Flavor

A creamy vanilla fudge base is combined with butterscotch, swirled with golden caramel, and finished with sea salt.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Buttery butterscotch richness
  • Caramel swirls and a touch of sea salt
  • A smooth vanilla fudge base
  • Handmade in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Caramel lovers, butterscotch fans, dessert gift boxes, and corporate gifts.

Ingredients: Sugar, cream, butter, vanilla, caramel, butterscotch chips, sea salt.

Each piece weighs ¼ pound. Gluten-free. Ships nationwide.

Caramel Cookie Dough: The Dough Must Go On

Caramel Cookie Dough: The Dough Must Go On

If cookie dough is good, cookie dough layered inside fudge is a very persuasive next step. The Dough Must Go On brings chocolate, cookie dough, and caramel together.

The Layers

A thick layer of milk chocolate fudge is topped with homemade edible chocolate chip cookie dough, another layer of chocolate fudge, and a buttery caramel drizzle.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Milk chocolate fudge layers
  • Homemade edible chocolate chip cookie dough center
  • Buttery caramel drizzle
  • Handmade in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Cookie dough lovers, chocolate-and-caramel fans, birthday celebrations, and gourmet dessert gifts.

Each piece weighs ¼ pound.

Chocolate Cheesecake

Chocolate Cheesecake

Why choose between chocolate and cheesecake? This swirl brings both dessert flavors together in one thick, creamy piece of fudge.

The Layers

Rich chocolate fudge and smooth cheesecake fudge are swirled together for a balance of chocolate richness and tangy cheesecake sweetness.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Chocolate and cheesecake fudge in one piece
  • A chocolate-and-cheesecake swirl
  • Rich, creamy texture
  • Handcrafted in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Chocolate lovers, cheesecake fans, birthdays, holiday gift boxes, and anyone who refuses to choose just one dessert.

Order online for nationwide shipping or visit Z. Cioccolato in San Francisco.

Chocolate Walnut: Oh Nuts!

Chocolate Walnut: Oh Nuts!

A timeless candy-shop classic. Oh Nuts! combines rich chocolate fudge and walnuts for a satisfying contrast of creamy and crunchy.

The Flavor

Smooth, creamy chocolate fudge is mixed with walnuts throughout, bringing chocolate flavor and nutty crunch to every piece.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Rich, creamy chocolate fudge
  • Walnuts mixed throughout
  • A classic chocolate-and-walnut combination
  • Handmade in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Chocolate and walnut lovers, nutty dessert fans, and gourmet fudge gift boxes.

Naturally gluten-free.

Please allow 3–5 days for us to ship the freshest fudge.

Cookies & Cream: Oreo Speedwagon

Cookies & Cream: Oreo Speedwagon

Cookies and cream had a perfectly good thing going. Then we made it fudge. Oreo Speedwagon keeps the classic combination simple and delightfully indulgent.

The Flavor

Oreo cookies are mixed throughout creamy vanilla fudge, bringing chocolate cookie crunch to a smooth vanilla base.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Creamy vanilla fudge
  • Oreo cookies mixed throughout
  • Chocolate cookie crunch
  • Handmade in San Francisco

Perfect For

Oreo fans, cookies-and-cream dessert lovers, and anyone who likes vanilla fudge with a little crunch.

Contains gluten.

Dark Chocolate Latte: Java the Hutt

Dark Chocolate Latte: Java the Hutt

Java the Hutt brings dark chocolate and caffe latte fudge together in one layered flavor.

The Layers

Dark chocolate fudge is layered with caffe latte fudge and drizzled with vanilla and dark chocolate fudge.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Dark chocolate and caffe latte fudge layers
  • Vanilla and dark chocolate fudge drizzle

Perfect For

Chocolate-and-coffee fans and a layered addition to a fudge assortment.

Please allow 3–5 days for us to ship the freshest fudge.

Dark Chocolate: The Dark Side

Dark Chocolate: The Dark Side

Sometimes the classics are the best. The Dark Side keeps the focus on dark chocolate.

The Flavor

This fudge is made with 100% dark chocolate from Ecuador, courtesy of Republica del Cacao.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Made with 100% dark chocolate from Ecuador
  • Chocolate sourced from Republica del Cacao

Perfect For

Dark chocolate lovers and anyone looking for a classic chocolate fudge.

Gluten-free.

Please allow 3–5 days for us to ship the freshest fudge.

Dark Sea Salt Caramel: Salty Little Thing

Dark Sea Salt Caramel: Salty Little Thing

Rich dark chocolate, buttery caramel, and a touch of salt make Salty Little Thing a classic sweet-and-salty indulgence.

The Flavor

A dark chocolate fudge base is swirled with buttery caramel and finished with sea salt. The smooth, creamy fudge contrasts with the caramel swirl in every thick square.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Rich dark chocolate fudge
  • Smooth, buttery caramel swirls
  • Sea salt for sweet-and-salty balance
  • Made fresh in San Francisco

Perfect For

Dark chocolate lovers, salted caramel fans, gourmet gift boxes, and a little everyday indulgence.

Gluten-free.

Espresso Dark Chocolate: Shot in the Dark

Espresso Dark Chocolate: Shot in the Dark

A little dark. A little dramatic. Probably judging your decaf. Shot in the Dark brings espresso dark chocolate fudge together with a swirl of milk chocolate fudge.

The Flavor

Espresso dark chocolate fudge is swirled with milk chocolate fudge for an espresso-inspired look.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Espresso dark chocolate fudge
  • A swirl of milk chocolate fudge
  • An espresso-inspired swirled appearance

Perfect For

Espresso fans, dark chocolate lovers, and anyone who likes their dessert with a little coffeehouse personality.

Heath English Toffee: Toff of the Morning

Heath English Toffee: Toff of the Morning

Chocolate, toffee, and caramel make a very convincing trio. Toff of the Morning brings them together in a creamy, crunchy fudge.

The Flavor

Rich chocolate fudge is packed with Heath English Toffee pieces and finished with a buttery caramel drizzle.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Rich, creamy chocolate fudge
  • Crunchy Heath English Toffee pieces
  • Buttery caramel drizzle
  • Handmade in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Chocolate and toffee lovers, Heath candy bar fans, gift boxes, and holiday treats.

Contains almonds.

Maple Walnut: Maple My Day

Maple Walnut: Maple My Day

Maple and walnuts make a classic team. Maple My Day pairs creamy maple fudge with its nutty partner.

The Flavor

Creamy maple fudge is blended with walnuts for a classic maple-and-walnut combination.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Creamy maple fudge
  • Walnuts blended throughout
  • A classic maple-and-walnut pairing

Perfect For

Maple fans, walnut lovers, and anyone who enjoys a classic nutty fudge.

Gluten-free.

Maple: Sappy Ending

Maple: Sappy Ending

Simple yet delicious. Sappy Ending is smooth, creamy maple fudge that keeps the spotlight on maple.

The Flavor

Warm maple flavor meets a buttery, smooth fudge texture. This recipe has no walnuts or other nuts added, so maple gets the whole stage.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Rich maple flavor
  • Smooth, creamy texture
  • No walnuts or other nuts added to the recipe
  • Handmade in small batches in San Francisco

Perfect For

Maple candy fans, maple dessert lovers, and anyone who prefers maple fudge without added walnuts.

Gluten-free.

Handmade by Z. Cioccolato in San Francisco.

Milk Chocolate: Choco Moo Moo

Milk Chocolate: Choco Moo Moo

No gimmicks, no drizzles, and no nonsense. Choco Moo Moo lets classic milk chocolate fudge speak for itself.

The Flavor

Silky and elegant milk chocolate fudge keeps this flavor simple.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Classic milk chocolate fudge
  • Silky texture
  • No drizzles or extra layers

Perfect For

Milk chocolate lovers and anyone who prefers a straightforward candy-shop classic.

Please allow 3–5 days for us to ship the freshest fudge.

Mint Chocolate: Mint Condition

Mint Chocolate: Mint Condition

Cool mint. Rich chocolate. Mint Condition brings a bright peppermint contrast to dark chocolate fudge.

The Layers

A deep layer of dark chocolate fudge is swirled with cool mint fudge for a creamy chocolate-and-peppermint combination.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Dark chocolate fudge
  • Cool peppermint fudge
  • A rich-and-refreshing flavor contrast
  • Handmade in small batches in San Francisco’s North Beach

Perfect For

Mint chocolate lovers, late-night sweet cravings, and a cool contrast in a fudge assortment.

Peanut Butter: Butter Me Up

Peanut Butter: Butter Me Up

Butter Me Up is exactly what its name promises: pure peanut butter fudge.

The Flavor

Peanut butter fudge takes center stage in this single-flavor choice.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Pure peanut butter fudge
  • A peanut butter-focused flavor

Perfect For

Peanut butter lovers and anyone who wants to keep their fudge choice simple.

Penuche Brown Sugar: Granny's Got Game

Penuche Brown Sugar: Granny's Got Game

Old-fashioned in the best way. Granny’s Got Game is the kind of fudge that takes you back to Grandma’s house—a little nostalgia in every bite.

The Flavor

This classic New England-style penuche fudge is made with a brown sugar base.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Classic New England-style penuche
  • A brown sugar fudge base
  • An old-fashioned favorite with a nostalgic feel

Perfect For

Brown sugar lovers and anyone craving a familiar treat that feels like a visit to Grandma’s house.

Pomegranate Dark Chocolate: Fall of Pompeii

Pomegranate Dark Chocolate: Fall of Pompeii

Rich dark chocolate. Bright pomegranate. A pink swirl with a flair for drama. Fall of Pompeii brings fruit and chocolate together in one striking piece of fudge.

The Layers

A pink pomegranate layer meets rich dark chocolate fudge, finished with a chocolate-and-pink swirl. Every piece looks a little different.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Dark chocolate paired with bright pomegranate flavor
  • A striking pink-and-chocolate swirl
  • Made fresh at Z. Cioccolato in San Francisco’s North Beach

Perfect For

Dark chocolate lovers, fruit-and-chocolate fans, and a custom fudge box that could use a little drama.

Each square is approximately 2 inches by 2 inches and weighs ¼ pound.

Pumpkin Spice Latte: Basic Witch

Pumpkin Spice Latte: Basic Witch

Coffeehouse cravings. Cozy fall spices. Absolutely no name misspelled on the cup.

Basic Witch turns your favorite autumn latte into a layered piece of pumpkin spice latte fudge. Made in small batches at Z. Cioccolato in San Francisco’s North Beach, it brings coffee, pumpkin, marshmallow, and dulce de leche together in one delightfully extra fall treat.

The Layers

Smooth, coffee-flavored latte fudge meets creamy pumpkin fudge infused with clove and nutmeg. A fluffy marshmallow “foam” layer tops it off, followed by a drizzle of pumpkin spice dulce de leche. Four layers. One cozy obsession.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Pumpkin spice latte flavor: Your seasonal coffeehouse favorite, reimagined as gourmet fudge.
  • Coffee and warm spices: Rich latte fudge balances creamy pumpkin, clove, and nutmeg.
  • A little extra indulgence: Marshmallow foam and pumpkin spice dulce de leche finish every piece.
  • Handcrafted in San Francisco: Made in small batches at Z. Cioccolato in North Beach.

Perfect For

Pumpkin spice lovers, coffee fans, fall birthdays, Halloween treats, Thanksgiving dessert tables, or anyone who starts sweater season while it’s still 85 degrees outside.

Add Basic Witch to your custom fudge box, order online for nationwide shipping, or visit Z. Cioccolato in San Francisco for a little taste of fall.

Gluten-Free Flavor

Please allow 3–5 days for us to prepare and ship your fresh fudge.

Vanilla Bean: Anything But Vanilla

Vanilla Bean: Anything But Vanilla

Made with real vanilla bean. Anything but boring. Anything But Vanilla puts authentic Madagascar vanilla beans in the spotlight.

The Flavor

Real Madagascar vanilla beans—and their vanilla bean bits—bring authentic vanilla flavor to this fudge.

Why You’ll Love It

  • Made with real Madagascar vanilla beans
  • Real vanilla bean bits in the fudge
  • Authentic vanilla flavor

Perfect For

Vanilla lovers and anyone who knows a classic flavor can still have plenty of personality.

Tip: Your box size determines how many flavors you can pick. Change the box size above to update the limit.

Each vegan piece adds $2 USD to your box price.

Customer Reviews

Overall rating: 5.0 / 5 from 13 reviews.

Absolutely delicious! The only problem I have is trying to not eat it all at once!

Choose Your Own Fudge Box

The only issue I have is how long it takes to have it shipped. Standard delivery takes about a week. It says 3-5 days but always seems to take longer. I have to remember to order well in advance to get there on time for a specific occasion. It’s kind of hit and miss. The expedited delivery fees are too high and almost as much as the product itself. Anyway, everyone I sent it to loved it so I will order again. I just wish you could do something about the delivery times and fees. It is an excellent product.

Choose Your Own Fudge Box

I'm a repeat customer, fudge is excellent! Love trying the new limited flavors but my all time favorite is the butterscotch caramel, delicious! Always order 1 of those in the 6pc box.

Choose Your Own Fudge Box

The dark chocolate and pomegranate is phenomenal! And the Pumpkin Spiced Latte is your best pumpkin flavor, per my coworkers and I!

Choose Your Own Fudge Box

incredible fudge, I've been eating it until I get sick every night since I got it

Choose Your Own Fudge Box

This fudge is the BEST! They have lots of different flavors to enjoy. It is always fresh. It’s such a treat to eat.

Choose Your Own Fudge Box

As usual you did not disappoint! I'm hooked on your pumpkin fudge. Smooth feel packed with flavor 🤤!!

Choose Your Own Fudge Box

This company makes the best fudge I've ever had. I live in New England, surrounded by local fudge companies, and none of them comes close to this.

Choose Your Own Fudge Box